Introduction to Jesus feeding the 5,000 (John 6.1-15)

feeding-5000.jpg


The four Gospel writers were not merely historical story tellers, but used the stories of Jesus for teaching purposes. Each author has his own particular emphasis as they recount how Jesus fed the 5,000. Jesus’ teaching is so rich, and each evangelist highlights one aspect. John’s vision becomes clear through the teaching in 6.25-59, the verbal form of Jesus’ miraculous sign. Closely linked to the preceding chapters, John 6 again underlines the glorious good news that Jesus brings life. Jesus is indeed himself “the bread of life“(John 6.35, 41, 48, 51). Here Jesus is depicted as parallel to, but distinct from the manna which God gave to Israel through Moses in the wilderness. Both with the manna and with Jesus,  life is given to all who will partake. But those who ate the manna eventually would die, whereas those who through faith “eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood” (6.53) have eternal life and will be raised up with Jesus at the last day (6.54).
So John uses the fact of Jesus’ feeding the 5,000 as further evidence of Jesus being the life-giving Messiah sent by the Father above.
Matthew, Mark and Luke also tell the story of the 5,000 to prove that Jesus is indeed the Messiah. This stands in contrast to John’s glorying in Jesus’ gift of abundant life here on earth and eternal life with the Father in glory. Another parallel and contrast is that all four evangelists tell the story of the 5,000, but only Matthew and Mark recount the feeding of the 4,000.
Matthew (14.13-21 and 15.29-39)
multitudes.jpg

As I have shown in my expository book “Matthew and Mission: the Gospel through Jewish eyes”, Matthew clearly shows that the 5,000 was a Jewish crowd while the 4,000 were Gentile. As an introduction to the feeding of the Gentile crowd Matthew attacks traditional views of what is kosher and what is unclean (Matthew 15.17-20). In those days Gentiles were considered to be unclean because they were outside the covenant of God. But Jesus eagerly desires to feed not only a crowd of his own Jewish people, but also a Gentile crowd. The new covenant reaches out to all peoples.
matthew mission 2.jpeg
This anti-legalism teaching is immediately followed by the account of Jesus healing a Gentile woman’s daughter (15.21-28) in spite of his principle calling to “the lost sheep of Israel”. So Jesus not only declares his acceptance of Gentiles as no longer unclean, but he also does a miracle for a Gentile woman. The door is now open for him to feed the Gentile crowd.
Matthew uses the story of Jesus feeding the two crowds to demonstrate the universality of Jesus’ purposes. And still today Jesus longs to feed the crowds of both Jews and Gentiles of every nation, tribe and tongue. It is totally unacceptable to call oneself a follower of Jesus and yet fail to have a worldwide mission passion.
In the final messianic banquet multitudes of believers from all nations will gather at the table of Abraham. It was therefore commonly believed that when the Messiah would come, he would feed the crowds from all nations. Feeding both a Jewish and a Gentile crowd is a clear sign that Jesus is the long-awaited Messiah.
Mark (6.30-44; 8.1-13 and 17-21)
5000 feeding 1.jpeg

As in Matthew’s Gospel, so also in Mark we find both the feeding of the 5,000 and of the 4,000. In Matthew, Mark and John the feeding of the 5,000 is immediately followed by the story of Jesus walking on the water, further evidence that Jesus is not just an ordinary man. He is the true Messiah, the very Son of God sent by the Father. Mark recounts the story of the 5,000 to show that Jesus is the Messiah, but unlike Matthew, Luke and John he doesn’t appear to have any further purpose.
Later, although the disciples had witnessed the miraculous feeding of both crowds, the disciples still worried about having no bread to eat. Jesus castigates their lack of understanding and faith. So he reminds them of the number of basketfuls of left-overs they had gathered. After feeding the Jewish crowd of 5,000 men they had picked up 12 basketfuls. And after the feeding of the Gentile crowd of 4,000 they had gathered 7 basketfuls. Twelve is the traditional number for Israel with its twelve tribes, while seven is the number which represents fullness and therefore relates to all peoples. 12 + 7 = Jew and Gentile. Jesus really is the Messiah who feeds all nations and peoples.
Luke (9.10-17)

luke_outline1.jpgAlthough Luke had accompanied Paul, the apostle to the Gentiles, in some of his missionary trips, nevertheless he only recounts the feeding of the Jewish crowd of 5,000 men. But the international Jew-and-Gentile context of this story is highly significant.
In 9.1 Jesus sends the twelve out in mission and then in 10.1 he sends out the 70 or 72. As we have just noted, the number 12 traditionally represents the people of Israel. Around the first century debate raged concerning what number should represent the Gentiles. Of course 7 stood for all peoples, Jew and Gentile. But was the number just for the Gentiles to be 70 or 72? The number 70 reminded people of the children of Noah, the forefathers of the Gentiles. 72 was 2 x 6 x 6. Six is one less than seven, the number of fullness and perfection. The Gentiles were considered less than perfect (!) and the multiplication of 2 x 6 x 6 underlined that inferiority. Interestingly there was some debate in the 1st century concerning how many scholars were involved in the Septuagint, the Gentile Greek translation of the Hebrew Scriptures, the Old Testament – 70 or 72? Likewise in Luke 10.1 some manuscripts have 70 and some 72. Jewish mission, the sending of the 12, is followed by Gentile mission with the 70 or 72.
As we might expect from our knowledge of the structure of the Book of Acts and Jesus’ significant relations with the Samaritans, in Luke 9.51-56 we find the Samaritans between Jewish mission and Gentile mission. The Samaritans are the bridge between Jews and Gentiles, opening the door for traditional Jewish followers of Jesus to reach out also to Gentiles unto the uttermost parts of the world. Jesus is very gracious. He does not parachute us into impossibly hostile mission territory, but helps us to widen our horizons more gradually, one step at a time.
It is in this context that Luke gives us the story of the feeding of the 5,000. And he underlines the messianic claims of Jesus by adding Peter’s confession of Jesus as Messiah and his account of the transfiguration to demonstrate the glory of Jesus. Having shown the messianic nature of Jesus in this way, he sees no need of telling the story of Jesus walking on the water immediately after the feeding of the 5,000. In this he differs from the other three Gospels.
Luke also makes it clear that Gentile mission will involve the disciples in considerable sacrifice. Between the Samaritan incident and the sending of the 70 or 72 Luke adds a few verses which warn of the cost of “service in the Kingdom of God” (Luke 9.62). Whatever the cost we are to follow the Lord and “go and proclaim the kingdom of God” (9.60). Having put our hand to the plough, we are not to look back.

bread of life.jpeg
Conclusion So we see the clear parallels between John’s account of the feeding of the 5,000 and the similar accounts of Jesus feeding the crowds in the other three Gospels. While all four Gospels underline the proof of Jesus as Messiah through this miraculous sign, John’s particular emphasis is that Jesus has come as the Bread of Life, the author of abundant and eternal life.

 

Advertisements
Categories: Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Post navigation

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: